Assessment in higher education: an overview of the impacts of teaching practices and student perceptions based on a systematic literature review

um panorama dos impactos das práticas docentes e das percepções dos estudantes a partir de uma revisão sistemática da literatura

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.1590/1982-57652025v30id293131

Keywords:

higher education, students perception, assessment practices

Abstract

The article presents a systematic literature review (SLR) with a view to understanding the main theoretical and practical perspectives mobilized in the production of knowledge on assessment in higher education. Methodologically, the search was conducted in online databases without time restrictions. Of the 206 articles identified, 52 formed the empirical corpus. The analysis was structured into four main dimensions, some of which included several categories: i) nature of the studies; ii) centrality of assessment; iii) teachers' assessment practices; and iv) students' perceptions of assessment practices. The results indicate a predominance of empirical studies and reveal that, despite resistance to the adoption of innovative practices, formative and participatory approaches have gained prominence. The review also points out that while many students perceive assessments as disconnected from everyday reality, those assessment practices that are more contextualized and accompanied by continuous feedback are viewed positively, promoting greater engagement and meaningful learning. The research suggests the need to overcome traditional practices and adopt assessment models that favor autonomy, critical reflection, and the applicability of knowledge in professional contexts, contributing to a more inclusive and transformative higher education. 

Author Biographies

  • Marcelo Pezzi, Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences of University of Port

    Marcelo Pezzi has a degree in Business Administration from the Federal University of Santa Catarina (1998) and a master's degree in Production Engineering from PPGEP/UFSC (2001). He is currently studying for a PhD at the Faculty of Psychology and Educational Sciences of the University of Porto (FPCEUP) - Portugal. He has worked as a Business Course Coordinator for 13 years and has been a lecturer at various HEIs in undergraduate and postgraduate courses. He has worked as a commercial pilot and small entrepreneur. He is currently working in public service as an EBTT professor at IFSC/Joinville, with exclusive dedication to the Hospital Management course. His main research interests are: Studies and research in the field of education; Continuing teacher training; Impacts of culture on teacher-student relations. Evaluation process and teacher feedback.

  • Doctor Amélia Veiga, Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences of University of Port

    AMÉLIA VEIGA is assistant professor at the Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences of University of Porto (FPCEUP) and researcher at the Centre for Research and Intervention in Education (CIIE) and collaborator at the Centre for Research in Higher Education Policies (CIPES). She has been researcher at the Agency for Assessment and Accreditation of Higher Education (A3ES). She holds a PhD on Educational Sciences by FPCEUP, Portugal. She has developed expertise on the Bologna process and has been involved in national and international projects on higher education governance in areas such as internationalisation, globalisation, quality assurance and research on teaching and learning. She has been publishing on European integration and governance and the institutionalisation of a European dimension in education. She is developing expertise in innovation in teaching and learning and research on pedagogies of higher education. She published several influential works on European integration, governance, and the institutionalisation of a European dimension in education.

  • Doctor Preciosa Fernandes, Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences of University of Port

    Preciosa Fernandes is Associate Professor at the Faculty of Psychology and Education Sciences of the University of Porto (FPCEUP). She is full member of the Centre of Research and Intervention in Education of the University of Porto (CIIE), co-leading the Curriculum, Evaluation, Teacher Education and Educative Technologies group (CAFTe). She is the Director of the Master Course in Health Education (in partnership with the Faculty of Medicine of UPORTO). She supervises PhD and Master¿s students in a variety of areas. Her main scientific research domains are: curriculum policies and practices, educational and school evaluation, teacher education and professional development, special education and health education and pedagogy in higher education. She has participated in a number of external national and international research projects on these issues. She is the PI of National project "Digital Platforms in School Clusters' Management" (2018-2021), and participates at the Spanish project "DEMOSpEJS - Democracy in Schools as the Cornerstone of an Education for Social Justice" (project no. EDU2017-82688-P, coord. by Demospaz/UAM - Universidad Autónoma de Madrid). Currently, she is also involved in a number of projects funded by the European Commission under Erasmus+: "Mind the Gaps ¿ Media Literacy Towards Youth Social Inclusion"; "BE PART - Youth-Led Development for School's Participatory Management"; "UP2B - Boosting Up Social Education towards European Citizenship and Labour Market Inclusion"; "The 21st Century Skills and the Global Goals for Sustainable Development: Towards Responsible Pupils of the Future"; and "ENGAGE STUDENTS ¿ Promoting Social Responsibility of Students by Embedding Service Learning within HEIs Curricula". She co-chaired, until 2015, the CIIE¿s Schools¿ Life Observatory (OBVIE), and she has extensive experience in researching and interacting in/with a wide range of primary and secondary schools. Since 2008, she has been serving as evaluator of the Portuguese General-Inspectorate of Education. She is reviewer of national and international journals. Her research has been published widely in national and international journals, and she is also co-author of several books, focusing on education, curriculum and learning assessment, and author of a book focused on curriculum policy.

Published

2025-12-10

Issue

Section

Artigo

How to Cite

Assessment in higher education: an overview of the impacts of teaching practices and student perceptions based on a systematic literature review: um panorama dos impactos das práticas docentes e das percepções dos estudantes a partir de uma revisão sistemática da literatura. Avaliação: Revista da Avaliação da Educação Superior, Campinas; Sorocaba, SP, v. 30, p. e025025, 2025. DOI: 10.1590/1982-57652025v30id293131. Disponível em: https://submission.scielo.br/index.php/aval/article/view/293131. Acesso em: 18 dec. 2025.